Notes · US pricing law

Where volume discounts are legal, state by state.

In most industries a case discount is just commerce. In American alcohol it is regulated state by state, and in several states it is flatly prohibited. This is the layer every price walk I build runs through: I check a discount ladder here before I put it in front of a client.

General guidance, not legal advice. US alcohol pricing law is state-specific, changes often, and is enforced by each state's alcohol authority. Confirm against the current statute, or qualified counsel, before building a discount structure on it. Last reviewed: June 15, 2026

The federal floor

Federal law sets the baseline. The FAA Act's tied-house and inducement rules bar discounts that are not open to every retailer on equal terms, and a quantity discount that fails that test is a common violation. Most states then go further, and it is the state rule, not the federal one, that decides what a distributor can actually offer.

The four regimes, in plain language

Open: Pricing is relatively free. Quantity discounts to retailers are generally permitted unless a specific rule says otherwise.
Post-and-hold: Wholesalers file their prices with the state and hold them for a set period. A discount has to appear in the posted schedule and be offered to every retailer on equal terms. Several of these states prohibit volume discounts outright.
Franchise: The law protects the supplier-distributor relationship itself and makes it hard to end. It shapes deal structure more than per-case discounting.
Control: The state is itself the wholesaler, the retailer, or both, so there is no private discounting to retail to negotiate. You work the board's listing process instead.

State by state

State	Regime	Volume discounts to retailers	In practice
New York	Post-and-hold	Prohibited	The state bans volume discounts to retailers outright. Wholesalers post prices monthly and hold them for the month; any discount must be in the posted schedule and uniform.
California	Open	Allowed	Relatively liberal: quantity discounts are generally permitted, provided they avoid tied-house inducements.
New Jersey	Open	Restricted	Discounts must be offered to all licensees of the same class on equal terms.
Illinois	Open	Allowed	Permitted, with equal-treatment constraints.
Florida	Open	Restricted	Confirm the current cash-law and equal-terms rules before relying on a discount.
Texas	Open	Restricted	TABC rules on discounts and cross-tier ownership apply; confirm before structuring.
Massachusetts	Post-and-hold	Prohibited	Volume discounts to retailers are restricted, and price postings apply.
Connecticut	Post-and-hold	Prohibited	A minimum-bottle and price-posting regime that leaves little room for discounting.
Pennsylvania	Control	Not applicable	The state board (PLCB) is the wholesaler and retailer; you engage its listing process instead.
Michigan	Control	Not applicable	A control state for spirits; wine rules differ, so confirm before assuming.

Any state not in the table: confirm with that state's alcohol authority before assuming anything. The absence of a row is not permission.

Outside the United States

United Kingdom: no three-tier system, and volume discounts are normal commercial practice. Watch the duty system, minimum unit pricing in Scotland and Wales, and competition rules on resale price maintenance.
France: quantity discounts are common, but resale below cost is prohibited and commercial terms are framed by the Code de commerce. Check your standard terms of sale.
Canada: provincial boards set retail prices, so private quantity discounting to retail does not apply. Trade pricing runs through each board's listing process.

Where this fits

A discount ladder is only worth building where it is legal. Tell me your states and I will tell you what you can actually offer.

Let's talk